Skip to content

Former state district judge completes pretrial diversion program, DWI charge dismissed

The drunken driving case against former state District Judge Robert Garza was dismissed last week after he completed a pretrial diversion program.

Judge Romero Molina — a visiting court-at-law judge who handled the case — dismissed two misdemeanor charges against Garza on Dec. 10.

“This is the way the program works,” said attorney Artemio De La Fuente of Edinburg, who represented Garza. “And if you successfully complete it, this is the reward.”

Roberto “Robert” Garza, 68, of Brownsville retired in 2005 after two decades on the bench.

After practicing law with his son, Garza became a visiting judge in 2017, according to information provided by the Fifth Administrative Judicial Region.

Former state District Judge Roberto “Robert” Garza, 68, of Brownsville. (Photo courtesy of the Hidalgo County Sheriff’s Office.)

The Palmview Police Department arrested Garza after a traffic stop on Dec. 19, 2018.

At 1:06 a.m., Officer Brenda Alaniz witnessed a blue BMW X1 speeding west on Expressway 83 near the Minnesota Road exit.

“As I was able to catch up to the vehicle, the driver of the vehicle refused to stop,” Alaniz wrote in her report, which accused Garza of ignoring her emergency lights.

Garza pulled over near the intersection of Expressway 83 and Business 83 in Peñitas.

When he opened the glove compartment, officers noticed that Garza had a handgun. They asked him to step out of the car.

Officers also noticed that Garza had bloodshot eyes and struggled to stand.

Garza said he’d been at “a gathering with some friends,” according to the report, and had been drinking beer.

Officer Gerardo Guerrero, who assisted with the traffic stop, asked Garza to perform a standard field sobriety test.

“He advised he couldn’t do it because he had injured his legs,” according to the report.

The officers asked Garza what brought him to Palmview at 1 a.m.

“Mr. Garza stated he went to eat and he ended up there,” according to the report. “Mr. Garza stated he did not know what he was doing there.”

While they were talking, Garza urinated on himself, according to the report.

Officers asked Garza to provide a breath sample.

He blew into a portable breath test, which showed Garza had a blood alcohol concentration of at least 0.154 — nearly twice the legal limit.

Officers arrested Garza and brought him back to the police department, where he refused to provide another breath sample.

Garza was charged with driving while intoxicated, a Class B misdemeanor; unlawfully carrying a weapon, a Class A misdemeanor; and evading arrest or detention with a vehicle, a third-degree felony.

The Hidalgo County District Attorney’s Office didn’t accept the felony charge.

“There was never a strong case for the state on that charge based on the facts of the case,” De La Fuente said.

Garza wasn’t familiar with the area, De La Fuente said, and wasn’t sure where to stop.

“As soon as the judge saw the opportunity to pull over, he did so,” De La Fuente said.

As part of the pretrial diversion program, Garza made an “admission of guilt” in December 2020.

Garza also promised to attend an alcohol education program, perform 24 hours of community service and submit to random alcohol testing.

The District Attorney’s Office filed a motion to dismiss the charges on Dec. 8.

“Defendant successfully completed Pre-Trial Diversion Program,” according to the motion, “and State elects not to prosecute.”


  1. Taryn J. White on December 17, 2021 at 9:10 am

    Most ordinary citizens who have to fightDUIcharges today, typically do not get the DWI dismissed entirely. Probably another case of rules for thee, not for me.

  2. Donald trump on December 17, 2021 at 11:17 am

    Thats the world we live in especially that county…the DA refused to accept the felony thats funny

Leave a Comment